Black Holes AND Ancient Indians

Albert Einstein felt nature would not permit such things to exist, despite his theory of general relativity allowed such a possibility.  It was unthinkable for him to have an enormous star; hundreds of times bigger than our sun could vanish from the universe.  An American journalist first named black holes in 1968 reporting on an American scientific meeting. ImageAmerican physicist, John Wheeler was the first one to describe an area of space which was “empty” and which “swallowed everything” including light.   Pierre-Simon Laplace and John Mitchell considered that such objects existed where the gravitational force was so great that light cannot escape in 18th Century, and were called “black stars” or “cold stars“.  In ancient Indian scripture, Mandukya Upanishad, probably composed around the second millennium BCE, talks about Vishwaruchi, which absorbs everything in the universe – Black Hole. Black holes were considered as scientific curiosities in the first half of the twentiImageeth century and belonged largely in science fiction.  It is only in the last couple of decades that their existence accepted by the scientific community.  It was popularised by movies such as Star Wars and TV programmes like Star Trek, Dr Who, Battle star Gallactica and Star gate.  Authors such as Larry Niven and Frederick Pohl used them as their theme in their novels. Image We now know that gravity does affect the time. If you are climbing a skyscraper, wearing an ultra-sensitive clock you will notice that the clock moves slightly slower as you reach the top, albeit by a billionth of a second.  The difference on a GPS satellite can be quite significant and hence the clocks on these satellites are constantly readjusted.  A black hole has enormous gravitational pull, strong enough to even hold the light in it, and nothing can escape a black hole.  Escape velocity from the weak earth’s gravity is about 7 miles per second.  Light travels at about 186282 miles per second.  Even this velocity is not enough to get light out of the gravitational pull of a black hole.  The only thing we know that is capable of travelling faster than light, is a quantum particle called Tachyon.  Even this has been described in the Mandukya Upanishad as Manojava.  The characteristics of both objects and particles are uncannily similar. Varahamihira described what could only be a gravitational force when he said, that there must be a force that keeps object stuck on the surface of the earth.  Later in the seventh century, Brahmagupta said the same thing about falling objects – “bodies fall towards the earth as it is in the nature of the earth to attract bodies.”  Image Sayana, a fourteenth century mathematician and teacher in Vijayanagara court, commenting on Rigveda, Book one, hymn 50, has described what appears to be the speed of light.  He quotes sunlight travelling 2202 yojanas in half a “nimisha.”  Taking each Yojana to be about 9 miles long and a nimisha is about 16/75th of a second; it works out to around 185794 miles per second.  That is a very close approximation of the speed of light.  He was writing in the fourteenth century AD about a Vedic composition probably dating back to 3000 BCE. Our sun is an average sized star about half way down its life cycle.  In about five billion years from now, the fuel in the sun will burn out, leaving a cold, dark mass the size of a few miles across, smaller than the size of earth.  A star, which is ten times the size of our sun, will have burnt up its fuel in time and collapse on itself into a neutrino star.  A neutrino star has massive gravitational pull.  If you drop a marshmallow on such a neutrino star, it will produce a force equivalent to a nuclear bomb. However, a star, which is twenty times the size of our sun, will collapse into a black hole with unimaginable gravitational pull.  Almost every galaxy in our universe has a black hole in its centre.  They are voracious eaters and swallow anything that comes close.  Some of them are vast, measuring thousands of light years across with a mass equivalent to millions of suns and some of them are miniscule rogue Black Holes wandering the interstellar space.  Despite their reputation of swallowing everything in their path, they do not really go chasing after objects. Ancient Hindu astronomy speaks of stars, other heavenly bodies disappearing, and a star devouring another star.   At a crude level, one could think of Rahu swallowing the sun causing the solar eclipse.  Ancient scriptures tell us about stars swallowing other stars. It has been described as a bottomless pit into which everything disappears.  However, they do have a bottom where the star has condensed into a tiniest mass.  Even though the size is tiny, the mass remains the same.  For example, when our sun collapses into a dark mass the size of a few miles across, our earth will stay in the same place with the same gravitational pull of the sun.  If we set off from the earth in a spacecraft and travel about 26000 light years towards the centre of our Milky Way galaxy we will reach the constellation of Sagittarius.  ImageThere is an area within the constellation where nothing can be seen. This has been termed Sag A*.  As we reach the edge of this area, the time slows down enormously.  Every minute spent in this zone called the ‘event horizon’ is equal to about a thousand years on earth.  If you manage to cross the ‘Event horizon’ the time stops for you.  Image In Hindu mythology, Brahma, the creator of the universe said to have  a life span of billions of years and his one day is equal to thousands of earth years.  Is it possible that the author of this hymn was indicating the event horizon and issues with the time space continuum?  Mandokya Upanishad describes the day of creator as 4.5 billion years of human time as day the same as night.  If we remember the big bang occurred around 13.8 billion years ago and the stars were formed around 9 million years ago, it seems a bit more than coincidence that these numbers match. Black holes do not just exist in the centre of galaxies, but there are rogue ones wandering around the galaxies devouring anything that came in their path. Our own galaxy has at least half a dozen such rogue black holes. What do these black holes have?  In a word, a lot of nothing.   That is not entirely true.  Anything that gets into the clutches of its gravitational pull gets compacted into small objects.  A regular sized black hole can compact a mountain the size of Mount Everest to the size of a grain of sand or less. Our own home planet can be compacted to the size of an eyeball.  Supermassive black holes are another matter altogether.  They would reduce our home planet to atomic size or less. They have masses equivalent to millions or even billions of suns.  Once anything reaches the centre of the Black Hole it will come to the region of ‘Singularity’ and all objects merge into this ‘Singularity’.  We know that the big bang started with the ultimate example of Singularity – a tiny speck 13.8 billion years ago and it is still expanding. Coming to the region of ‘Event horizon’ or the point of no return.  When and if you manage to reach the area just before ‘Event horizon’ area, every minute spent there is equal to thousand years at home on earth.  If you manage to cross the event horizon, someone looking from earth will see you frozen in time. However, nothing is infinite.  Stephen Hawking theorises that there is a “leak” from the black holes at an infinitesimal slow rate. You will have to wait a trillion or two earth years before you can escape.   As you fall through the black hole, you are stretched and shred to pieces and as you reach the centre, you become one with the black hole.  You have reached “Singularity”. This begs the question or several questions.   Did the ancient Indians know about the black holes and the Event horizon five thousand years ago?  Did they know that the time moves slower nearer the centre of gravity than, say a global positioning satellite (GPS)?  Did they know that a minute near the event horizon is equal to thousands of earth years?  When they quoted the creator’s time as millions or billions of years, were they being metaphorical? When one becomes one with the Black Hole in ‘Singularity’, is one merging with the Creator, as Hindu’s believe? So far, no black hole has been imaged. That is until now. The black Hole in Sag A* in the centre of our own Milky Way galaxy, is due to have its dinner within next twelve months or do.  A gas cloud is nearing the event horizon and every capable telescope is being pointed at this spot to catch a once in a millennium occurrence. The entire globe is being converted into a massive telescope to watch this feeding frenzy. We will not be able to see the black hole, but we can see what happens to the Gas cloud G.  We will be able to see left overs at the table.





Filed under Uncategorized

27 responses to “Black Holes AND Ancient Indians

  1. Sumir Saini

    Dear Shankar Kashyap Ji,

    Really hats off to you… Very well written. Thank you.

  2. rahul

    I am just surprised after reading all this, you opened the door of new thinking with endless possibilities about universe and ignored or miss understanded ancient indian science and provoked me to create forests of questions and trying to find their answers…Thank you for explaining it very easily…

    • You are welcome. My idea is for making people think and make their own minds up about ancient texts and theories!! History always repeats itself – someone cleverer than me said it!!

  3. rithik singh

    Sir is black hole is the terminal to any another world

    • If yes can we control time and if we control time we will never die ……….

    • No one really knows what is inside a Black hole. Once you pass the ‘event horizon’, time ‘stops’ and if you survive, you will be merged into a single dot called ‘singularity’ – that is the theory!! Nothing, not even light escapes a Black Hole. However, Black holes do spit out constantly, material “swallowed” and if you can create a another Black Hole, the two of them get connected by a Worm hole and link to the other side of the Galaxy or even the other side of our universe. I am not quite sure if it can connect to “other universes” in the Multiverse theory!!
      I hope this helps.

  4. Sashi

    Great explanation. I am a true believer in ancient Indian science. I was sure that somewhere in our Vedas there should be mentioning of black hole but in a different terminology. Thanks again.

  5. Ishan Bodh

    Great post Sir you have a vast imagination….Can you tell me how we know that everything shrinks after event horizon? And is it possible that after event horizon gravitational pull ends..??

    • We don’t really know that anything “shrinks” after entering the Black Hole! Astrophysicists tell me that the gravitational pull gets exponentially stronger (theoretical) once the event horizon is passed and everything is condensed into a “singularity” due to enormous gravitational pull. I hope I have explained this correctly.

  6. S Kumar

    Imagination? All of this are facts buddy.

    Tks Shankar sir, it was a really nicely written article. Really stunned to think that we had so much knowledge, lost them and now watching discovery channel documentaries. Similar to your article is talks by ‘Khurshed Batliwala’. I just hope we realize more of our own knowledge.

  7. Sudeep

    Like Albert Enstine said, we should not forget about highly intellectual civilisation was thriving when our western society lived in darkness. Hinduism is ocean of knowledge where no subject is been left to discribe.

  8. Arvind Pradhan

    it is clear from your article that the Indian astronomers and philosophers were very advanced in their understanding of universe. Without the benefit of today’s technology, they came to the same conclusions as the western scientists of today but many centuries ago. Hats off to them. Thank you for your excellent article.


    Your explanation is excellent. I will advise all of my friends to read this article very well. Hope this helped us to know about the black hole and ancient Indians scriptures which is richest than all .

  10. vishwendra

    Great article sir.
    What is ur take on fifth dimension?.. As shown in the movie interstellar.
    Have ancient Hindus written about it?.

    • The “Prana” or the force that our sages used can’t be anything other than the fifth dimension. It can’t be explained by any other means. Just because we still don’t understand it perfectly does not mean it did not exist!

  11. scanner

    “If you are climbing a skyscraper, wearing an ultra-sensitive clock you will notice that the clock moves slightly slower as you reach the top, albeit by a billionth of a second.”

    Are you sure ? Or is it the opposite ?

    • You right. I should have made it clear that it would occur only if one is in space because of “time delation”!

      • scanner

        Indeed it is “time dilation”. But in case of your example as the person is climbing a skyscraper, he is actually moving away from the gravity and thus time will speed up for him. This is “Gravitational Time Dilation”.
        This is applicable in space too. But also in that case if you are moving at very high speed then time will slow down for you as compared to others. This is “Relativistic Time Dilation”.

  12. Pingback: Black Holes AND Ancient Indians | Paradise Lost by author Mollie Bach (Lord)

  13. Ravikumar Kakde

    Yes, ancient Indians knew about ‘Black Holes’. Not only that black hole eats everything but they twist time and space around them and gives out relativistic jets of energy and house a galaxy around. They knew exactly what is a black hole.
    Be the part of newly discovered knowledge given in this book:
    “Brahma Gyan – The science behind Shiva” by Ravikumar Kakde. (available on amazon)

  14. Thank you Ravikumar. I will certainly have a look at your book. Sounds very interesting.

  15. Srinivas

    Really hats off Sir.. I am eagerly waiting for such posts which relate our vedas and ancient writings with the on-going discoveries. I strongly believe that there is a lot written in our vedas and it would definitely help us to understand the universe more. Unfortunately, I do not know where to start with to know more. I want your suggestion on which ancient writing to start with, to understand the universe. Which of our ancient stack explains universe in detailed (including black holes, gravitation, dark matter/energy, etc…). Is there any writing that speaks about gravitons or any other so called god particle?

    • Thank you Srinivas. There are several books which deal with these – too many to go through here. You could try some books by David Frawley, Srikanth Talageri, Georg Fuerstein and not to forget Stephen Hawking. Bhagavatas deal with the Vedic interpretation of the God particle and the Black hole, particularly dealing with the event horizon.
      Best of luck. You will spend next few years going through them!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s